[TruthLies]

SPECIAL NOTE - some homicide/arson/vice cases allow you to pick who to charge with the crime. In some cases, only one choice gives you 5 stars, so i will make note of whom to choose in the individual cases in which this applies.

Homicide Case 1 - Red Lipstick Murder

Evidence at scene:

writing on body - examine victim's abdomen
blunt force trauma - examine victim's head
missing jewelry - examine victim's left hand
size 8 shoe prints - found at evidence marker C
lipstick - in purse at Marker A
bamba club lighter - evidence Marker B, move other pieces in relation to bottom one on globe to open it

At Bamba club in interview with Dick McColl:

license plate 2B8899 - pick "truth" for topic "suspect seen with victim"
husband's alibi - pick "doubt" for topic "knowledge of husband"

Celine Henry's resident:

female shoe - floor of dining room
forced entry - examine broken window in kitchen
missing jewelry - examine empty Tiffany box in bedroom
marital problems - in cut-scene conversation with next door neighbor at their house

Jacob Henry's apartment:

size 11 shoes - in suitcase in bedroom
death threat note - revealed with pencil on pad on table near kitchen

Mendez's apartment:

size 8 shoes - in bedroom on floor
used lipstick - in box on bedroom floor
socket wrench - in same box on bedroom floor

Dick McColl - at Bamba club

suspect seen with victim - truth
knowledge of husband - doubt
ring stolen from victim - doubt

Jacob Henry - at his apartment

movements of victim - lie - bamba club lighter
last contact with victim - truth
motive for murder - lie - death threat note

Jacob Henry - police station

lipstick markings - truth
deterioration of marriage - lie - marital problems
access to murder weapon - lie - husband's alibi
missing jewelry - truth

Homicide Case 2 - The Golden Butterfly

Evidence at scene:

rope pattern - examine victim's neck
missing jewelry - examine victim's left hand
small men's footprints - evidence marker C

Moller residence:

size 8 work boots - in master bedroom
missing watch and rings - examine items on dresser
husband's alibi - when talking to Michelle, pick "doubt" for topic "last contact with victim"
butterfly brooch - also talking to Michelle, pick "doubt" for topic "state of parent's marriage"
bloody shoes - in incinerator outside after chase

Central morgue:

size 8 footprints - examine plaster mold on counter

Belmont HS:

butterfly brooch - given from suspect after chase
rope - in trunk of car in parking lot
bloody tire iron - also in trunk
overalls - also in trunk

Michelle Moller - interviewed at Moller residence

last contact with victim - doubt
missing watch and rings - truth
state of parent's marriage - doubt

Hugo Moller - outside of residence

footprints at crime scene - lie - size 8 work boots
missing person's report - doubt
alibi for Hugo Moller - lie - husband's alibi
history of violence - lie - butterfly brooch

Hugo Moller - police station

disposal of evidence - truth
access to braided rope - doubt
access to tire iron - lie - bloody tire iron
victim's vehicle recovered - lie - overalls

Eli Rooney - police station

footprints at scene - doubt
place of employment - doubt
access to braided rope - truth
motive for Moller murder - doubt

Homicide Case 3 - The Silk Stocking Murder

Evidence at scene:

bloodied stocking - evidence marker A
blood trail - near marker A
ladies' hat - by the door at the end of the first blood trail
personal effects - added as you find the shoe in the trash can as you follow the blood trail
key - hanging on a pipe later in the blood trail
dot pattern note - folded paper on ground after the key blood trail
library card - first half found with body, second half at end of trail on corner of last rooftop

Antonia's Apt:

broken window - examine the window on the right
iron picket - found by examining the broken window
charm bracelet photo - on top of the dresser
attorney's letter - in envelope found in suitcase on bed
religious necklace - added when talking to the landlord, no specific responses needed

Maldonado residence:

Bloodied shirt - in the kitchen, the shirt is hung near the back, examine it
Husband's alibi - added after speaking to woman in 302 down the hall

Police station:

brown ford coupe - when interviewing Angel, use the husband's alibi after choosing lie for the topic "last contact with victim"

El Dorado bar:

divorce papers - given to you by bartender, examine envelope to open it

Just Picked Fruit:

scalpel - sitting on the desk in the back office/ room

Barbara Lapenti - boarding house

possible suspects - truth
movements of victim - doubt
evidence of break-in - lie - broken window or iron picket
breakdown of marriage - lie - charm bracelet photo (doesn't make sense to me either, haha)

Angel Maldonado - police station

last contact with victim - lie - husband's alibi
jewelry taken from body - truth
divorce proceedings - lie - divorce papers or attorney's letter
bloodstained shirt found - doubt

Diego Aguilar - El Dorado bar

movements of victim - truth
missing jewelry - doubt

Clem Feeney - Just Picked store

distinctive necklace - doubt
contact with victim - doubt
movements of victim - truth

Homicide Case 4 - The White Shoe Slaying

Evidence at scene:

time of death - added as you speak with the coroner
laundry label - when examining the victim's head on the left side on the back of the clothing, examine the label
boot prints - evidence marker B
tire tracks - evidence marker C

Superior Laundry Services:

laundry ledger - tap on "Mrs. T. Taraldson

Taraldson Residence:

matchbook for Baron's Bar - near the chess set on the table in the living room
victim's handbag - found in the laundry room, examine her ID
wet jacket - turn around after examining the purse in the laundry room to find this
muddy boots - also in laundry room, at back of room against wall
bow rope - easily missable as this is outside, found at the end of the boat toward the street in the driveway

SPECIAL NOTE - This case can be completed in many ways, but to find all evidence you have to go in a specific order, so i will try to outline that by ordering the evidence locations accordingly.

Baron's bar:

yellow cab 3591 - in talking to Benny, pick "Truth" for last contact with victim topic

TRACE AND FOLLOW YELLOW CAB

victim's movements - added only if you are able to interview the driver of the cab

Police station:

all american 249 - added if you pick "doubt" for topic movements prior to murder when interviewing Jessop

Interstate Bus depot:

bus route map - given to you by clerk at counter

PURSUE AND STOP BUS

victim last seen - added in talking to bus driver

Hobo Camp:

bloodstained rope piece - on nightstand next to bed in Ackerman's shack
purse - turn around from there and the purse is on the other table (and a newspaper is there, too)

Catherine Barton - at scene

suspicious persons - truth

Lars Taraldsen - at residence

possible suspects - lie - bow rope
alibi for lars taraldsen - doubt
victim's state of mind - doubt
last contact with victim - lie - wet jacket or muddy boots

Benny Cuff - baron's bar

last contact with victim - truth
vagrant male suspect - doubt
yellow cab 3591 - truth

Richard Bates - after chase at bar

contact with victim - doubt
account of movements - doubt

James Jessop - police station

contact with victim - doubt
incident with bates - doubt
cab ride with victim - doubt
movements prior to murder - doubt

Stuart Ackerman - police station (later in the case)

motive for murder - lie - bloodstained rope
contact with victim - doubt
alibi for stuart ackerman - lie - purse

Homicide Case 5 - The Studio Secretary Murder

pawned rings - added as you get the case briefing in the opening cinematic

Evidence at scene:

time of death -
vagrancy -
missing ring -
handbag -
upper half of torn letter -
movie lot job -
lipstick -

Levine's Liquor Store:

book - in back sleeping area of store - SPECIAL NOTE - return immediately to Mench's bar after finishing investigating the liquor store because it opens up a final question for mccaffrey - if you call dispatch for the address first, he is not in the bar anymore - you CAN ask him about the book at the police station later, but it doesn't add the key piece of evidence "victim last seen" anymore
liquor purchase - select truth for the topic contact with victim when talking to Robbins

McCaffrey's Apartment:

torn letter bottom half - on desk in living room
tire iron - on the floor near the desk in the living room

Police station:

SPECIAL NOTE - This is where the case gets tricky. You need to interview both suspects two times, in the right order, to get the last 3 pieces of evidence. Also, you can charge both men, but only charging McCaffrey will get you 5 stars. So, here we go.

This is the interview order: Tiernan, then McCaffrey, then Tiernan again, THEN CALL R&I IN THE HALLWAY, then McCaffrey to end the case.

Tiernan's accusation - added for picking doubt for the topic access to murder weapon
McCaffrey's accusation - added for picking lie for the topic access to tire iron and use Tiernan's accusation as the evidence selected
McCaffrey's criminal record - added after calling R&I to ask following second interview with Tiernan